Review: Tokaido Duo
Introduction & Overview
Shikoku may be the smallest of Japan’s four main islands, yet it is one of the busiest! Pilgrims travel across the land paying homage at its temples while contemplating the beautiful gardens; merchants haul their trinkets in search of unmatched profits; and artists delight in every landscape, turning each encounter into a learning experience.

Such is the premise of Tokaido Duo, the two-player reimplementation of Tokaido, both designed by Antoine Bauza (Takenoko, 7 Wonders). It was first published in 2022 by Funforge in a French edition. Artwork is handled by Xavier Gueniffey Durin, better known as Naïade, who previously illustrated Tokaido as well as other games like Seasons and Lords of Xidit.
Published in Spanish by Asmodee (the game is completely language-independent, except for the rulebook), it allows for 2-player games with a suggested minimum age of 8 and an approximate playing time of 30 minutes. The retail price is €24.99. For this review, a review copy of the Spanish edition was kindly provided by Asmodee.

Important: if you already know the game and/or are only interested in my opinion about it, you can go directly to the Opinion section. The Content and Mechanics sections are especially intended for those who do not know the game and prefer to get a general idea of how it works.
Components
Inside a two-piece cardboard box (lid and bottom) measuring 19.5×19.5×4.5 cm (a small square box similar to games like Kahuna or Trambahn), we find the following components:
- Main Board (cardboard)
- 6 Character Boards (cardboard)
- 6 Pawns (3 of each color) (wood)
- 8 Trade Tokens (cardboard)
- 26 Goods Tokens (cardboard)
- 20 Painting Tiles (cardboard)
- 4 Markers (2 of each color) (wood)
- Hot Spring Token (cardboard)
- 3 Wave Tokens (cardboard)
- 24 Coins (cardboard):
- 20 Value 1
- 4 Value 5
- 12 Gold Ingots (cardboard)
- 3 Dice (wood)
- Cloth Bag
- Rulebook

How to Play
Tokaido Duo is a two-player-only game set on the Japanese island of Shikoku, where each player controls three different characters (a pilgrim, a merchant, and an artist) aiming to make the most of their combined activities. The game is played over alternating turns in which the active player rolls three custom dice and drafts one; next, their opponent chooses one of the remaining two, and the starting player takes the last one. Upon drafting a die, the player must move the corresponding character an exact number of spaces equal to the die’s value (without passing through the same space twice in a single movement) in order to carry out the destination space’s action: the pilgrim travels around the island’s perimeter visiting temples and gardens to advance their markers on both tracks, the merchant follows the inland trade routes to acquire and sell goods so as to accumulate coins and gold ingots, and the artist journeys across the various regions painting landscapes to give away their painting tiles and clear their board. The game ends at the conclusion of the turn in which a player reaches the end of either the temple or garden track with their pilgrim, obtains their sixth gold ingot with their merchant, or gives away their tenth painting with their artist. At that point, the points earned by each character are added up: the product of the values reached on the pilgrim’s temple and garden tracks, the score shown on the last ingot obtained by the merchant, and the highest uncovered value on the artist’s board. The player with the highest total score is declared the winner.
Key Concepts
Let’s start with the Main Board. It depicts a large central island featuring a coastal perimeter route with several stages that are also connected by paths to four inland towns, dividing the island into a series of regions marked with a symbol. At the top, there is a reserve area for upgrades.

Moving across this board are the three Pawns controlled by each player: the artist (who moves between the inland regions), the merchant (who travels along the inland paths), and the pilgrim (who moves along the coastal route). The only particularity is that on the coastal route stages, there can only be one pawn per space (whereas in the inland areas, both towns and regions, multiple pawns may coexist).

To move their pawns, players roll and draft Movement Dice. There is one die associated with each pawn featuring 3 possible movement values (1, 2, and 3), with each value appearing twice. The single golden rule is that when moving a pawn, it must take the exact number of steps shown on the die (no more, no less).

Each pawn has a distinct role. The artist aims to create paintings in order to subsequently give them away. These paintings are represented by rectangular tiles in the player’s color depicting a landscape. To give away a painting, the player’s pawn must be in the region matching that landscape. Every painting given away provides points at the end of the game.

The merchant seeks to acquire Gold Ingots. These are earned by accumulating 10 coins, represented by tokens worth 1 and 5. In order to earn these coins, the player will need to trade.

To do so, they visit the inland towns to obtain Goods, represented by tokens of four types: kimonos, pottery, dolls, and fans.

These goods are sold in coastal towns that feature an associated market, represented by Market Tiles indicating the demanded item and how many coins are received per unit sold.

The pilgrim, meanwhile, advances along two tracks while also being able to collect coins and, above all, acquire upgrades that boost the abilities of the player’s pawns.

Finally, each player has three Player Boards, each linked to one of their pawns. The pilgrim’s board features 2 tracks—one for temples and one for gardens—where the corresponding marker advances one space each time the pilgrim visits that location. On the merchant’s board, there is a reserve for five goods and a lower section for placing gold ingots with their associated victory point values. The third belongs to the artist, holding their 10 paintings initially facedown, which are sequentially revealed and given away to award the victory points printed on the uncovered spaces.

That is enough to get started.
Preparación de la Partida
- Place the board in the center of the table.
- Shuffle the market tokens and place one on each coastal town.
- Place the hot spring token on its designated space.
- Place the upgrade tokens on either side in the reserve area.
- Put all the goods tokens into the cloth bag.
- Form a general supply with the coins and gold ingots.
- Set the three dice aside.
- Each player chooses a color and takes a divider, 3 character boards, 2 pilgrim markers (placed on the starting spaces of each track on the pilgrim board), 10 paintings (shuffled and placed facedown on the artist board), and three pawns placed on their indicated starting spaces on the main board.
- Finally, determine the starting player.
We are ready to begin!

Game Flow
A game of Tokaido Duo unfolds over an undetermined number of rounds. At the start of each round, the starting player takes all three dice and rolls them, creating a common dice pool.
After this, three alternating turns are played: the first by the starting player, the second by their opponent, and the third once again by the starting player.
On each turn, the active player must draft one of the available dice, move the corresponding pawn the exact number of steps shown (without passing through the same area twice), and, if possible, resolve an action at the destination space. Play then passes to the opponent.
The round ends once all three dice have been activated, and whoever was not the starting player in the concluding round becomes the starting player for the next one. A new round then begins.

Each pawn operates as follows:
- Artist: must move across as many regions by crossing borders as the value on the die. In the destination region, they may:
- Paint: this allows flipping over as many paintings (proceeding from left to right and top to bottom) as the number of pawns located on spaces bordering that region.
- Gift: the player returns their lowest-value revealed painting to the box if it matches the landscape of the region where the artist ended their movement.
- Merchant: the player moves the merchant between points along the inland paths. Depending on the destination, a different action can be resolved:
- Mountain Town (inland): The player draws as many goods from the bag as indicated by the town. Afterward, they check if they exceed the 5-goods limit, returning any excess to the bag.
- Coastal Town (perimeter): The player returns to the bag as many goods tokens matching the town’s market token as they wish, receiving the indicated number of coins for each. If the player subsequently holds 10 or more coins, they exchange every 10 coins (returned to the supply) for a gold ingot (placed from left to right on the merchant board). Note that coastal towns can only be occupied by a single pawn (of any player and any type).
- Pilgrim: the player advances their pilgrim clockwise as many spaces as indicated by the die value, skipping over spaces occupied by other pawns. Afterward, they trigger the effect of the space where they stopped:
- Temple: advance the red marker one space on their pilgrim board.
- Garden: advance the green marker one space on their pilgrim board.
- Coastal Town: gain as many coins as the selling value of the corresponding good.
- Hot Spring: take the hot spring token, which allows taking a double turn (activating the same die twice) on a future turn (returning the token to its space afterward). If the opponent holds the token, take it from them to gain control of it.
- Coast: the player chooses one of the three available upgrades and places it on the corresponding character board. If none remain available, they may take one from their opponent. While an effect token rests on a character, that pawn benefits from the corresponding perk.
Game End
The end of the game is triggered when a player manages to fully develop one of their three pawns, meaning:
- Either of the pilgrim’s two markers reaches the end of its respective track.
- The merchant accumulates five gold ingots.
- The artist has given away all of their paintings.
The current round is completed, and players proceed to final scoring, where each player tallies:
- Pilgrim: multiply the value on the red track by the value shown on the green track.
- Merchant: score the points indicated on the rightmost gold ingot on their board.
- Artist: score the points shown on the highest-value uncovered space.
The player with the most victory points wins. In the event of a tie, the victory is shared.
Personal Opinion
The pandemic marked a turning point in board game design. The tabletop market boomed as an ideal pastime during a period when people were forced to stay home and socialize with their household. Since many people live alone or with a partner, solo and two-player games experienced a massive surge in popularity.
Within the two-player niche, following the tremendous success of 7 Wonders Duel (check out its tocho-review here), we have been flooded with two-player adaptations of established titles tacking the word “Duel” onto their names. Examples include Splendor Duel (check out its tocho-review here), Imhotep: The Duel, Sobek: The Duel, Kingdomino Duel, and Cosmic Encounter Duel (check out its tocho-review here). While similar spin-offs already existed—such as The Pillars of the Earth: Builders Duel or Catan: The Duel—this trend has noticeably accelerated.

That is why Antoine Bauza seized the opportunity to revisit another of his major commercial hits (though less critically acclaimed), Tokaido. It is time to examine what this Tokaido Duel brings to the table and how closely it resembles the original design, though not before thanking Asmodee for the review copy that made this lengthy write-up possible.
In Tokaido, players took control of pilgrims traveling the famous route connecting Tokyo (then Edo) to Kyoto. The goal was to complete the most spiritually fulfilling journey using a time-track turn system. Under this mechanism, the player furthest behind on the track became the active player and decided how far forward to advance their pawn, blocking that space until their next turn (save for mandatory intermediate inns that accommodated everyone). At each stop, the player resolved a location-based action that generally helped build various sets, continuing until everyone reached the end of the road.
It was a mechanically very simple game with minimal depth that left me rather cold back in the day, even though I lacked the board gaming background I possess today. Even then, it struck me as quite mediocre. That is precisely why this two-player version piqued my interest—I wanted to see if good old Bauza could push things further and deliver a more compelling design.

In Tokaido Duo, the core premise shifts dramatically. Gone is the linear progression with a “time-track” mechanism; instead, we move to a round-based structure with odd-numbered turns where the starting player gets two turns (the first and the last) while their opponent gets only one (the second).
Furthermore, each player controls not just one pawn, but three, each pursuing a distinct goal: the pilgrim (who most closely mirrors the original game’s pawn, moving along a track—now circular—to visit various locations), the artist (who seeks to create works of art and subsequently gift them), and the merchant (who aims to turn a profit by acquiring goods in certain locations and selling them elsewhere).
At the start of each round, the active player rolls three dice, each linked to one of these pawns. On every turn, the active player drafts one die and moves the matching pawn according to its specific movement rules to resolve its action, continuing until the endgame is triggered once a player fully develops one of their characters.

And there really isn’t much more mystery to it. You simply alternate turns picking the most advantageous option given the current board state—either because it is the most beneficial move for your corresponding pawn, or because it denies a lucrative play to your opponent (assuming they don’t get to pick first).
First off, I will say that I consider it a better game than Tokaido. Here, there is an actual decision embedded in the draft. Granted, that choice is often obvious: if it is your turn to pick and, say, the merchant die is available with the exact value needed to reach the town buying fans at top dollar while you hold 4 fans in your reserve, there isn’t much to weigh. The same goes for the pilgrim, whose rolled value might offer something enticing (like landing on a garden) or something lackluster by comparison (like landing on a resource-selling space).
True, it is nothing groundbreaking, yet these evaluations feel more engaging than what Tokaido offered. Having said that, being better than Tokaido does not automatically make it a game worth recommending. Ultimately, Tokaido Duo also slips into mediocrity, largely because a very clear optimal pattern emerges during play.

That pattern is none other than focusing heavily on the merchant. Provided luck is on your side, this pawn is the easiest to max out. Generating an ingot over 2–3 merchant activations is relatively straightforward, meaning the starting player will likely draft this die on their first turn unless its movement value simply fails to align with their plans.
Consequently, players are practically forced to trade activations of this character, because if one player activates the merchant noticeably more often than their opponent, their victory becomes highly probable. Not only will they end up triggering the game’s end, but the point differential will be massive, as it is very difficult to match the merchant’s output over the same number of turns using the pilgrim or, especially, the artist, who accumulates points at the slowest pace.
Admittedly, luck plays a significant role when operating the merchant, since drawing one good of each type differs vastly from pulling matching goods that enable highly efficient sales. Even with poor luck, however, it is hard to spend two merchant turns visiting mountain towns without accumulating 2–3 goods of the same type, leaving you merely waiting for a turn to visit the right coastal town.

While the artist may score the most slowly, they do so steadily, as it is rare to be unable to gift a painting—making it worthwhile to paint as many canvases as possible in early turns. Meanwhile, the pilgrim generates the most player interaction, since spaces occupied by pawns are skipped over by an advancing pilgrim.
Thus, keeping your pilgrim parked on key spaces like the hot spring or a garden is a clever way to block your opponent from enjoying that spot and force them to leapfrog you. Still, reaching such a scenario usually means one player has activated their pilgrim far more than the other, as both pawns behave much like a track cycling pursuit race, starting on opposite sides of the ring and trying to catch one another.
There is a tiny sliver of variability courtesy of the upgrades set out during setup, which can provide a fairly substantial boost during the game, particularly if acquired early on. However, this falls far short of compensating for the rest of a design that is, at best, forgettable. As mentioned, there are no glaring mechanical flaws to point out—yet there are barely any standout virtues either.

People sometimes praise games of this ilk for their gentle nature, designed simply to enjoy a pleasant session free of conflict or heavy brain-burning. While there is certainly a time and place for a more relaxed gaming experience, the reality is that there are heaps of titles fitting that bill that are vastly more entertaining and that I would recommend well ahead of Tokaido Duo. Take Pelican Bay (check out its tocho-review here), for instance: even though I don’t openly recommend it due to its propensity to induce analysis paralysis, it feels like a “zen” design with far more substance than the one we are examining today.
Turning to production quality, we are met with somewhat lackluster materials, featuring thin, loosely pressed cardboard for the tokens. While the wooden pawns boast original shapes with decent density and paintwork, and the wooden dice are perfectly fine, the vast majority of components are cardboard. The rulebook is reasonably well-structured and leaves no room for ambiguity.
On the visual front, we once again have Naïade wielding the brushes, which is always cause for celebration. If Tokaido stood out for anything, it was the extraordinary elegance of the French artist’s graphic design and illustrations, dominated by crisp white tones that evoke peace and tranquility. That winning formula returns here, sporting a nearly immaculate cover save for the two characters occupying the center, alongside a board displaying only paths and interconnected locations against a stark white backdrop accented with subtle motifs. Very handsome indeed.

And let’s wrap this up. Tokaido Duo is the two-player adaptation of one of Antoine Bauza’s most overrated designs. While it improves upon the original game and introduces a few interesting choices during play, they are not enough to make it a recommendable title—especially once you spot the imbalance among the different paths available, which diminishes the weight of those decisions. The game remains just as gorgeous as the original, though production opts for somewhat subpar materials. It isn’t a disaster and is perfectly playable, yet it never rises above mediocrity. For all these reasons, I give it a…


